Inconsistently Consistent

Paradoxes keep reappearing, like the inconsistently consistent way I write and publish my thoughts here.

They sneak up in my everyday encounters and attempts at routines. Like my ‘daily’ (sometimes once a week or whenever I can) practice of writing lists - a whatever comes to mind, walking list.

One list came to me in the middle of the night, written on September 17th, 2020, after moving to a new city in a pandemic while also under the threat of wild fires.

weight is the.png

It became a poem embedded in the sculpture, Stack of Words, made from a balancing act of modular components.

Something about a secret poem that couldn’t be read shelved within an absurd sculpture made of everything from: packaging cardboard to carpet padding, embroidery thread, a twig and copper wire to plaster and repurposed wood, a leaf and a rock, plaster and cement, bicycle tire tubes and a ceramic candelabra. It represented a layered complexity that words felt incapable of containing.

Paradoxes like ‘alone together’ emerged for many as a mantra at the beginning of the pandemic, but it was the oxymoron, ‘faraway nearby,’ the title of Rebecca Solnit’s collection of essays, which had been living with me prior.

The title itself is said by Solnit to be gleaned from the painter, Georgia O’Keefe, noting the way she signed her letters after she moved to New Mexico, although as of yet, I’ve only found a painting with this title.

Solnit’s words, ‘The Familiar Edge of the Unknown,’ became the title of my recent two-person exhibition with painter, Tanner Lind.

Video courtesy of Alan Viramontes

"The bigness of the world is redemption. Despair compresses you into a small space, and a depression is literally a hollow in the ground. To dig deeper into the self, to go underground, is sometimes necessary, but so is the other route of getting out of yourself, into the larger world, into the openness in which you need not clutch your story and your troubles so tightly to your chest. Being able to travel both ways matters, and sometimes the way back into the heart of the question begins by going outward and beyond. This is the expansiveness that sometimes comes literally in a landscape or that tugs you out of yourself in a story...just to know that the ocean went on for many thousands of miles was to know that there was an outer border to my own story, and even to human stories and that something else picked up beyond. It was the familiar edge of the unknown, forever licking at the shore." 

pg.31 Rebecca Solnit, The Faraway Nearby

My individual work featured in the exhibition was about what Solnit describes as going underground, ‘the digging deep.’ I had dived head first into personal experience, private conversations and inner dialogues.

In many ways, I was referring to a category of study that the artist and writer, Moyra Davey defines as ‘the Wet.’ In her essay, The Wet and The Dry (The Social Life of the Book), ‘the Wet’ is introduced as a problem, a ‘welling up’ of something not ready to be told, what cannot be faced, the opposite of ‘the Dry.’

Installation View

Installation View

This process of working is a visual language of in-betweens, similar to how Jan Verwoert defines abstraction in his essay, The Beauty and Politics of Latency: On the Work of Tomma Abts. It holds two or more things at once, what Verwoert describes as “temporal latency in twofold: that which is not yet and that which is no longer present…an echo chamber of the yet unthought and the presently forgotten.”

It is not that unlike how Davey details her ‘daily rehearsal of lost and found,’ the moments of looking for what-was and the feeling of there it is.

“The ritual is about creating a lacuna, a pocket of time into which I will disappear…Lost and found is a ritual of redemption. If I find the thing then I am a worthy person. I have been granted a reprieve…I know this ritual is a rehearsal for all the inevitable, bigger losses. I think if I can only find X, then I am holding back the floodwaters, I am in control.”

Moyra Davey, Index Cards

(Left) Why Can’t You Hear Me?, 2020, (Right) Is It You?, 2020

(Left) Why Can’t You Hear Me?, 2020, (Right) Is It You?, 2020

My own lost and found story occurred on a late afternoon, in the middle of summer. The branches were swaying in a welcomed breeze when I found Allison Cobb reading from her recently published book, Plastic, An Autobiography. Sitting in 1122 Outside, a backyard gallery, I listened, to her detail ‘the yes’ and ‘the no’ as a different way of saying ‘the Wet’ and ‘the Dry.’

It was my own ‘yes’ and ‘no’ that led me to accidentally, yet eagerly, join a poetry reading I didn’t know was going to happen. In a series of unfortunate events: wrong turns that I couldn’t correct until seven miles later, the spraying of sticky cold-brew coffee, fumbling the dates for hotels and arriving without a place to stay; a heat wave and an early fire season, accompanied by the hazy skies above the dry desert and the blood orange ominous sun that I’ve seen more than I’d like to. This was my no, my hell no.

The color of the sky during the fires, September 2020, Portland OR

The color of the sky during the fires, September 2020, Portland OR

Yet, each spill, wrong turn and incorrect combination of numbered dates are what led me to my yes. To the happenstance of sitting at a new-to-me place at the right time on the right day after driving through the night to return to where I started. The no meeting the yes.

The bizarre shift of unexpected circumstances, in under 24 hours lead me to sitting on a bench listening to Cobb read aloud.

“ I am the no and the yes - a line from the poet 'Annah Sobelman’s first book. It has lived with me for years, sometimes whispering through my mind in its old remembered rhythm.”

IMG_1612.jpg

As I continued to read on my own, I found Cobb pulling this line along, entangled in her writing; explaining her own lived experiences and identifying them in others.

Found in both the pages of Cobb’s book as well as beside her at the backyard podium, I listened and witnessed as visual artist and third generation atomic bomb survivor, Yukiyo Kawano described how she constructs her ‘no,’ as life-sized sculptures of bombs made with her ‘yes’ - deconstructed kimonos from her grandmother, weaving them back together with her own hair.

I also learned about Eve Tuck, scholar, Unangax̂, an enrolled member of the Aleut Community of St. Paul, Alaska, and Associate Professor of Critical Race and Indigenous Studies at the University of Toronto. Tuck is identified as having a “yes that takes the no with it, desire as synonymous with life in all its contradictory, disconcerting complexity.”

“Desire, yes, accounts for the loss and despair, but also the hope, the visions, the wisdom of lived lives and communities. Desire is involved with the not yet and, at times, the not anymore…desire is about longing, about a present that is enriched by both the past and the future. It is integral to our humanness.”

Eve Tuck, Suspending Damage, a Letter to Communities

I find my ceramic work to be a similar desire - an effort to encapsulate the truth of contradictions. I approach this material as a novice, asking the impossible to stand with its head held high, but instead of being disappointed by its inevitable slump and pull of gravity, I am intrigued by the attempts. These surprising moments where expectations have folded in on themself, but still stand, if only slightly; remaining as a failure to fail.

Notes V.jpg

Defining Anthropocene

Last month I was invited by Pacific Northwest College of Art’s Low Residency Creative Writing Program to participate in an EcoPoetics Workshop led by Allison Cobb, author of, “Plastic: An Autobiography.”

My definition of the word Anthropocene is Constellations of Scattered Bones & Hand Me Down Snippets, 2018, made mostly from beach collections

Prior to the class, I was asked to read Linda Russo’s “Counter Desecration: A Glossary for Writing Within the Anthropocene,” and to write my own definition of the word Anthropocene - a word I felt embarrassed to have never heard before.

Anthropocene Definition.jpg

Attempting to disregard my intimidation, I did a deep dive into Russo’s compiled glossary. I was comforted by the notion that this collection of curated definitions is presented as a guide of “roomy questions,” concerned less with answers and more with possibilities of uncovering new and future methods.

language: a living archive. A communal lung that holds and remembers all things through us. Made between our bodies, language lives everywhere. It travels and absorbs. A neural interconnectivity; the kinetic sensation is felt by all. It is composed of edges, imposes edges, but has no edges. It is a phenomenal organism, an extended nervous system that we all share. Capacious and metamorphic, infinitely adaptable, composed of and running through everything: all the meat of our bodies, this recyclable air, the earth and the universe that suspends it, all the physical spaces that contain us, and even all of the invisible, silent or silenced spaces where language rests, waiting for us to bring our attention through sound. Language absorbs all things: silt, soil, your ear against air, each word, earth against the mouth. To make room, in language, for language, listen closely. See repair.

-Counter Desecration: A Glossary for Writing Within the Anthropocene, Danielle Vogel*

Interdisciplinary artist, Christine Howard Sandoval’s practice is also a glossary of definitions that unpack cultural, economic, and social framings similar to how Russo pinpoints intersections across and within disciplines that determine ecological relationships.

Christine Howard Sandoval, (Left to Right), Land Form II- Diversion (diptych), 2018, Land Form III-Mother Ditch (diptych), 2019, Land Form I-Distribution (diptych), 2018, Adobe mud and graphite on paper, 52 x 40 inches on view at Disjecta Contemporary Art Center as part of the exhibition Timelines For The Future

Exhibited at Disjecta Contemporary Art Center as part of Timelines For The Future, Howard Sandoval’s glossary is defined by materiality, situated within the specificity of contested lands of Native and Hispanic heritage.

The multi-media passage of sculpture, video installation and mixed media drawings in the work of Channel trace the history of complex relationships between agrarian societies with riparian rights and land uses in the present; poetically using language to also identify a multiplicity of meanings that a word can hold simultaneously.

Still Image of Christine Howard Sandoval’s Channel 2017,  three-channel HD video with sound 7:43, taken during my visit to Disjecta Contemporary Art Center’s exhibition of Timelines For The Future, curated by Lucy Cotter

Still Image of Christine Howard Sandoval’s Channel 2017, three-channel HD video with sound 7:43, taken during my visit to Disjecta Contemporary Art Center’s exhibition of Timelines For The Future, curated by Lucy Cotter

My experience encountering Channel within a gallery space felt like an invitation to be still and present in Howard Sandoval’s movements: her meandering walk, witnessing the carrying and placing of found offerings, her running her hand against the surface of the land, all the while hearing her footsteps, the water beneath her feet. I listened to her calming voice narrate:

“ Without water there is no irrigation. Without irrigation the land will be lost. Without the land base the family will disintegrate and without family the community will die. Without community the language will be lost. Without language we do not exist.”

In the EcoPoetics Workshop, Cobb discussed questions of ethics, desire, grief, trauma and responsibility (response - ability, ability to respond); burrowing further into the meaning of language through nets cast by etymologies.

Excerpts of etymology research shared by Allison Cobb during an EcoPoetics Workshop, 2021

I was asked to respond and use my ability to collect plastic and to pair words with my findings - to speak about a method in prose poetry. Methods could be a point of view, a sound, an approach or theme, a story -maybe it is image and metaphor.

In searching for methods to define Anthropocene, I was reminded of the Danish artist group, SUPERFLEX (established by Jakob Fenger, Bjørnstjerne Reuter Christiansen and Rasmus Nielsen). In 2019 they exhibited a large scale site-specific installation, It Is Not The End of The World, flooding Cisternerne, a former water reservoir turned underground contemporary art venue in Copenhagen.

Me walking through It Is Not The End of The World, by SUPERFLEX at Cisternerne in 2019 ((click for video and sound snippet)

It Is Not The End of The World used language to make both a declarative statement and instigate curious reactions, begging the question: if it isn’t the end of the world, then what is it?

In visiting this exhibition, viewers like myself became active participants, wading through the dark halls in provided waterproof boots, experiencing a dystopian future not that unlike our present and imagining a world void of humanity, but not the end of the world itself.

In the center of the exhibition was an exacting replica of the executive toilets of the Bonn headquarters of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), flooded with commentary on global consequences caused by human consumption.

Almost a year after wading through the Cisternerne, I found myself in Portland, Oregon, talking with Jay Ponteri, Director of Low Residency MFA in Creative Writing at PNCA and the one who invited me to attend Cobb’s EcoPoetics Workshop.

It was by happenstance that we met beyond the virtual world of our online classroom. Our chance encounter was also simultaneously an unexpected opportunity to collect leftover materials from former students, of which was ironically a copy of Colors Magazine, specifically #82, a 2011 fall edition on Shit: A Survival Guide.

(Left) the cover of Colors Magazine #82, Shit: A Survival Guide under a pile of dog shit in the snow, (Right) Pages 6-7 of Diarrhea in the first section of Danger: Biohazard

The entire edition is exclusively and thoroughly dedicated to the topic of poop - its many names, stigmas, dangers and underrated resources from different locations around the world. It cites that nearly two-thirds of the world, who have no toilet, must live intimately with shit.

Colors Magazine #82, Shit: A Survival Guide, pages 44-45 from the chapter, Do-It-Yourself, referencing the work of Dr. Kamal Kar and the Community-Led Total Sanitation Foundation

A complicated aspect of defining Anthropocene is its entanglement with social and economic systems such as but not limited to capitalism, classism, settler colonialism, and systemic racism. Ten years later, Colors magazine could very well make an updated survival guide substituting the word shit for Anthropocene.

Yet, reducing a complex definition to a smelly pile of feces is about as paralyzing as the (valid) feelings of helplessness and grief that often results from discussions centered around climate change and environmentalism. Rather lets refer back to Linda Russo’s glossary. See repair.

repair: begin with what you have. Here, a clutch of syllables tied with blue string - carnation, elderflower, gardenia, thyme, and thistle. A white candle. A ring of hair. Ink. Let it warp. To gather all absences through a door in a tongue. Silence to sound to skin, to restore all things. See language.

-Counter Desecration: A Glossary for Writing Within the Anthropocene, Danielle Vogel*

Using Vogel’s definition of repair, I attempted to start with what I had. At the time Portland was experiencing a snow and ice storm and Portland General Electric was reporting at least 4,000 power lines down, leaving tens of thousands of people without power (myself included).

Wearing extra layers and taking cues from the late Dadaist, Tristan Tzara’s chance instructions on composing poetry, I took my copy of Shit: A Survival Guide and began to cut out text, rearranging them in a new order.

These words live in my latest installation, Sentences I Keep Near, forming a different type of survival guide.

Sentences I Keep Near, mixed media, 2020-21

*Edit 7/9/22 It has come to my attention that I incorrectly cited Linda Russo as defining language and repair While Russo compiled the glossary, these definitions were written by Danielle Vogel.Counter Desecration: A Glossary for Writing Within the Anthropocene,” is a collection of ecopoetic definitions by a collection of various contributors.